Wednesday, April 22, 2009

The fetal conundrum

People especially liberals often assume if you take the pro-life position that they can guess with a rather high degree of accuracy your position on other issues, some pro-choice whiners at Danny's place a few months back assumed quite naturally that I was for the war in Iraq but for me I take each issue as it comes. A theme has emerged at my blog of late and that is I don't apply social conservatism across the board. I'm on the record, on porn and prostitution I am very libertarian and with gay marriage I have no problem with the federalist approach although you'd have to put a gun to my head to attend the gay nuptials ("ok I'm getting dressed just let me find my tie"). BUT abortion is different my friends and that's because it's very very unique from the three big issues I just mentioned. Those have a personal element of distaste for so many by their very nature, my God just think Eliot Spitezer in nothing but his black socks but these issues generally do not involve the taking of an innocent human life (ok, generally speaking). For the average liberal though he glumps them all together into some kind of collective trauma of keeping the government out of our lives, actually out of our sexual lives because he does care very very much if you smoke or use an aerosol can. For the liberal with a conscience abortion is resolved this way: from a biological perspective he or she readily admits it's a human life, he's very personally against it as he's always fond of saying but because that human life resides for a time within a woman's body it ipso facto becomes a feminist issue, a women's rights issue not so much because of the nature of the fetus as he has pretty much figured this out by now but by the sit'chayshen. He or she can't get it out of his damn head that because the home of the fetus is the womb that the homeowner as property owner can do as she likes, it's nothing personal. She might see the fetus as an intruder although truth be told she answered the door when the penis rang. I'm a bad person because I only see the human life, I ain't sophisticated like Bill Moyers you know? I just know how to spit chickens.

8 comments:

  1. How backwards is that way of thinking that you are a bad person because you speak for those who cannot speak for themselves?

    As I put in that comment on page 2 now, abortion isn't one of those social issues between consenting adults, the child has no say which is why those of us who can speak for them do.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really think this is the proper framing of the issue, obob after all is very much for gay marriage but says the child deserves a chance. Soapie applies the Randian formula of liberty across the board, I find this problematic as each issue is different in its own way and I say abortion is the most serious.

    ReplyDelete
  3. BB seems to steer clear of these conversations, how does a scientist frame the issue of abortion?

    ReplyDelete
  4. He's dropped hints though, oh has he dropped hints!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for visiting my blog a while ago - I've been a bit inactive for a while.... I enjoyed reading your blog. I couldn't agree with this post on abortion more. Thanks for stating it so clearly!!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey, I just gotta ask, how do you spit chickens?

    ReplyDelete
  7. I really think the legs need to go into the flame, a chef told me this once. The other way ain't wrong but it's rookie. Also use a half-flame, it takes longer but the chickens won't burn and dry out and hey don't first wait for a reading of 185 before taking 'em off, go with no more than 165. For the best way visit a Boston Market near you.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanx red voice but it really comes down to this. Libs don't really have a problem with the entity of the fetus, it's just the location that makes them take the position they do. This is why pro-lifers giving them fetal development seminars don't work although I used to think so, the fetus is part of a process being experienced by the Woman and so she has final say. I don't agree with this in the least of course just trying to get inside their heads.

    ReplyDelete